By Kelsey Andersen
Calgary police are on the search for a self-proclaimed white supremacist, Kyle Robert McKee, 24, and a teenager, 17, in suspicion of leaving explosives and devices outside an apartment unit, that were later detonated in a parking lot near by.
There are warrants out for the arrest of McKee and the 17-year-old male that cannot be named under the Youth Criminal Justice Act. They are wanted on charges of attempted murder; possessing, making or controlling explosives; and possessing a weapon or an imitation for a dangerous purpose.
Calgary officials say that McKee has relations to a white supremacist group in Calgary, but they also believe that this was not a hate crime.
Staff Sgt. Keith Cain said Monday, “It’s not really a concern who they’re linked too,” then later on goes onto saying “Anyone using a bomb is a serious concern for us and obviously we want to locate these persons and get them under arrest, or in a custody, as soon as possible.”
Police responded to gunshots were heard Saturday morning in the block of 5300 on Rundlehorn Drive N.E.
A ground floor resident of the apartment building heard a noise outside and found two home made bombs, Cain said. The man then threw the devices into the parking lot where they exploded.
“If he hasn’t had thrown it away, he could have been injured inside, but if he has picked it up three or four seconds later, he could have been killed or injured throwing it away,” duty Insp. Frank Reuser said Saturday. “So it’s one of those situation where you’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t.”
In the parking lot, a vehicle was damaged but no one was hurt.
This article is very eye-opening. It shows that Calgary has many other kind of gangs that aren't drug related but race. It shows that ideologies of the early 1900's are still being practiced. This article didn't have an author, but it comes from a trustworthy source (CBC).
With love, LAST BLOG.
Anonymous (November 23, 2009), Neo-Nazi sought for attempted murder in bomb attack, CBC News, retrieved November 27, 2009 from http://www.cbc.ca/canada/calgary/story/2009/11/23/calgary-explosives-apartment-rundlehorn-mckee.html
Friday, November 27, 2009
By Megan Eichhorn
On November 19, 2009, Calgary Herald’s Jason Van Rassel reported that local gangster Roland Chin was denied release from prison because they parole board was not convinced his claims were legitimate. Chin says he is not a gang member but rather is friends with some of them through his brother, who died in a gang-related shooting. Chin claims he wants to get an education and a job. He is also paranoid and says he is scared for his life. He does “heat checks” and wears a bulletproof vest.
This article briefly quoted a parole board member. Chin was quoted heavily throughout the article, which emphasized his struggle and paranoia of gang conflict. This is the first article I have come across that seems to sympathize with an alleged gang member. It is very focused on Chin’s feelings about the situation, how it has affected him and what he wants to do about it. Van Rassel doesn’t speak ill of the police force, but he doesn’t do much in giving evidence that supports them either.
I would be surprised to find anymore articles that sympathize with an alleged gang member. I assume that most media reports will follow the previous trend of supporting and praising the work of the police in decreasing gang activity, thus increasing public safety.
Van Rassel, J. (2009, November 19). Calgary gangster feared for safety outside jail. Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 23, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/technology/Calgary+gangster+feared+safety+outside+jail/2237412/story.html
On November 19, 2009, Calgary Herald’s Jason Van Rassel reported that local gangster Roland Chin was denied release from prison because they parole board was not convinced his claims were legitimate. Chin says he is not a gang member but rather is friends with some of them through his brother, who died in a gang-related shooting. Chin claims he wants to get an education and a job. He is also paranoid and says he is scared for his life. He does “heat checks” and wears a bulletproof vest.
This article briefly quoted a parole board member. Chin was quoted heavily throughout the article, which emphasized his struggle and paranoia of gang conflict. This is the first article I have come across that seems to sympathize with an alleged gang member. It is very focused on Chin’s feelings about the situation, how it has affected him and what he wants to do about it. Van Rassel doesn’t speak ill of the police force, but he doesn’t do much in giving evidence that supports them either.
I would be surprised to find anymore articles that sympathize with an alleged gang member. I assume that most media reports will follow the previous trend of supporting and praising the work of the police in decreasing gang activity, thus increasing public safety.
Van Rassel, J. (2009, November 19). Calgary gangster feared for safety outside jail. Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 23, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/technology/Calgary+gangster+feared+safety+outside+jail/2237412/story.html
By James Wilt
On November 18th, 2009 the Calgary Herald published an article titled ‘Calgary police fear spread of poppy-based street drug’. The report was authored by Richard Cuthbertson, who has also written recent articles on crime-related topics including the ongoing trial of Jackie Tran, and the November 11th incident in which the Calgary Police shot a man in the north-east of the city.
Within ‘Calgary police fear spread of poppy-based street drug’, Cuthbertson extensively detailed the growing problem of ‘doda’ (the street name of the poppy-based drug) in Calgary. More specifically, Cuthbertson described how the drug is produced, the physical effects of it, the predominant users, the past police response, the quantitative results of a recent bust, and the police action plan for the future.
To accompany the facts, Cuthbertson utilized quotes from a MLA in the Calgary-McCall riding, a staff sergeant from the Calgary drug unit, the founder of Drug Awareness Foundation Calgary, and a director with Radio Sursangam in Calgary. Cuthbertson also mentioned on several occasions that gang-related activity in regards to ‘doda’ will increase as the drug grows more popular. The mentioned staff sergeant was quoted as stating that “Once you start getting into money, organized crime becomes involved and if organized crime becomes involved, there will always be that potential for violence”, giving additional support to the claim.
From an analytical perspective, Richard Cuthbertson excellently authored the report. He maintained an extremely fact-based, objective approach and presented the information in a clear, concise method.
An uninformed reader regarding the issue (such as myself) could easily gain an understanding of it from reading the 873 word article, which is a definite accomplishment for Cuthbertson. The fact that he included four completely distinct personalities (from a politician to a radio director) in the story contributed significantly to the objectivity and well-roundedness of the report. Although I can typically find some sort of fault in the stories I utilize for my analytical blogs, Cuthbertson’s article emerged completely unscathed.
To conclude, it can be determined that Richard Cuthbertson authored a great article in which he managed to preserve impartiality and authenticity while presenting a compelling, relevant report.
Cuthbertson, R. (2009, November 18). Calgary police fear spread of poppy-based street drug [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
On November 18th, 2009 the Calgary Herald published an article titled ‘Calgary police fear spread of poppy-based street drug’. The report was authored by Richard Cuthbertson, who has also written recent articles on crime-related topics including the ongoing trial of Jackie Tran, and the November 11th incident in which the Calgary Police shot a man in the north-east of the city.
Within ‘Calgary police fear spread of poppy-based street drug’, Cuthbertson extensively detailed the growing problem of ‘doda’ (the street name of the poppy-based drug) in Calgary. More specifically, Cuthbertson described how the drug is produced, the physical effects of it, the predominant users, the past police response, the quantitative results of a recent bust, and the police action plan for the future.
To accompany the facts, Cuthbertson utilized quotes from a MLA in the Calgary-McCall riding, a staff sergeant from the Calgary drug unit, the founder of Drug Awareness Foundation Calgary, and a director with Radio Sursangam in Calgary. Cuthbertson also mentioned on several occasions that gang-related activity in regards to ‘doda’ will increase as the drug grows more popular. The mentioned staff sergeant was quoted as stating that “Once you start getting into money, organized crime becomes involved and if organized crime becomes involved, there will always be that potential for violence”, giving additional support to the claim.
From an analytical perspective, Richard Cuthbertson excellently authored the report. He maintained an extremely fact-based, objective approach and presented the information in a clear, concise method.
An uninformed reader regarding the issue (such as myself) could easily gain an understanding of it from reading the 873 word article, which is a definite accomplishment for Cuthbertson. The fact that he included four completely distinct personalities (from a politician to a radio director) in the story contributed significantly to the objectivity and well-roundedness of the report. Although I can typically find some sort of fault in the stories I utilize for my analytical blogs, Cuthbertson’s article emerged completely unscathed.
To conclude, it can be determined that Richard Cuthbertson authored a great article in which he managed to preserve impartiality and authenticity while presenting a compelling, relevant report.
Cuthbertson, R. (2009, November 18). Calgary police fear spread of poppy-based street drug [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
Gangster Feels Unsafe in Freedom
By Nicolle Amyotte
Jason Van Rassel’s article from November 19 pertaining to Calgary gang member, Roland Chin, illustrates a side of gang warfare that is not often considered, the quality of life that gangsters have after serving time in jail. The article almost invokes sympathy for the criminal in the sense that it gives personal details about his life and encourages the reader to look at the world from his perspective.
A conversation back and forth between Chin and a parole board official is also mentioned, including the quote, “I just want to preserve my life”. Chin speaks of wearing a bulletproof vest and doing maneuvers while driving to test whether or not he is being followed.
Adversely, the article suggests that Chin’s decision to return to Calgary after imprisonment shows a lack of change in the individual. He has not distanced himself greatly enough from his previous gang activity, and therefore the parole board does not feel he should be released.
This article was probably published to inform from both sides of the issue. I feel that it performs this function quite effectively.
Reference:
Van Rassel, J. (19 November 2009) Calgary gang member feared for safety outside jail. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 26, 2009 from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Calgary+gangster+feared+safety+outside+jail/2237412/story.html
Jason Van Rassel’s article from November 19 pertaining to Calgary gang member, Roland Chin, illustrates a side of gang warfare that is not often considered, the quality of life that gangsters have after serving time in jail. The article almost invokes sympathy for the criminal in the sense that it gives personal details about his life and encourages the reader to look at the world from his perspective.
A conversation back and forth between Chin and a parole board official is also mentioned, including the quote, “I just want to preserve my life”. Chin speaks of wearing a bulletproof vest and doing maneuvers while driving to test whether or not he is being followed.
Adversely, the article suggests that Chin’s decision to return to Calgary after imprisonment shows a lack of change in the individual. He has not distanced himself greatly enough from his previous gang activity, and therefore the parole board does not feel he should be released.
This article was probably published to inform from both sides of the issue. I feel that it performs this function quite effectively.
Reference:
Van Rassel, J. (19 November 2009) Calgary gang member feared for safety outside jail. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 26, 2009 from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Calgary+gangster+feared+safety+outside+jail/2237412/story.html
Thursday, November 19, 2009
By Kelsey Andersen
Canada Border Services has deported two criminals. One of the criminals is known to be involved in a high-profile lethal case between rival gangs in Calgary.
Sunwoong Youn, also known as Jason Youn was deported to Korea last month. Mauricio Orellana, said to be an active gang member in Medicine Hat was also deported to his native homeland, El Salvador, this month. Both of these deportations were because of serious criminality, and permanently banned from returning, Canada Border Service Agency spokeswoman Lisa White said.
“These removals send a clear message the CBSA is committed to removing those who break our laws and endanger the safety and security of Canadians,” she added.
Police Chief Rick Hanson agrees with the deportation of Youn, who he referred to as "A sufficiently high-up player" in the gang realm. Not only applauding the deportation, Hanson is also questioning why it takes long periods of time to have known criminals kicked out of Canada. “It’s taken four years,” he said.
“The question again has to be asked, ‘Is four years a reasonable amount of time?’”
Hanson states that not only do such individuals pose a huge risk just by criminal involvement, but “they have nothing to lose” given pending deportation, which only increases the risks the pose.
“The ones that should be sent back should be sent back a lot quicker than they are,” Hanson claims.
“This is a long convoluted process and the last consideration is they safety of society.”
Hanson thinks that the media has accumulated more than enough attention about deportation through the Jackie Tran case, an alleged gang member who has been fighting his deportation for years now.
“It has allowed for public debate so people can see for themselves the frustrations we see," he said. "It has allowed people to formulate their own opinions; it is not just police beating the drum."
In 2002, Younn survived a mall shooting, but a bullet ended up lodged in his spine, causing paralysis in his leg and bowel problems. During this incidence, FK member Linju Ly was said to be the driver of the car, and Michael Oduneye the gunman.
Six days later, Ly was gunned down.
Over the years, time and resources have been spent on monitoring Younn while he has been residing in the community. Younn was convicted in 2005 of weapons-related offences while Cardona had convictions of drug-relations.
I believe Nadia, once again, did a great job on getting the story out. The article does allow for an opinion to form but I believe that there is no bias set up in this story. This story is very relevant to our blog, and it’s proximity.
It raises issues that many Calgarians’ probably do not think about, and raises the awareness on this topic. It shows the dark side and the bright side of deportation, something that the public should be more aware and concerned about. This story is compelling, and I’m sure it is going to the get attention that it deserves.
N.Moharib (November 13, 2009) Two Alberta criminals deported [Electronic Version] Calgary Sun
Canada Border Services has deported two criminals. One of the criminals is known to be involved in a high-profile lethal case between rival gangs in Calgary.
Sunwoong Youn, also known as Jason Youn was deported to Korea last month. Mauricio Orellana, said to be an active gang member in Medicine Hat was also deported to his native homeland, El Salvador, this month. Both of these deportations were because of serious criminality, and permanently banned from returning, Canada Border Service Agency spokeswoman Lisa White said.
“These removals send a clear message the CBSA is committed to removing those who break our laws and endanger the safety and security of Canadians,” she added.
Police Chief Rick Hanson agrees with the deportation of Youn, who he referred to as "A sufficiently high-up player" in the gang realm. Not only applauding the deportation, Hanson is also questioning why it takes long periods of time to have known criminals kicked out of Canada. “It’s taken four years,” he said.
“The question again has to be asked, ‘Is four years a reasonable amount of time?’”
Hanson states that not only do such individuals pose a huge risk just by criminal involvement, but “they have nothing to lose” given pending deportation, which only increases the risks the pose.
“The ones that should be sent back should be sent back a lot quicker than they are,” Hanson claims.
“This is a long convoluted process and the last consideration is they safety of society.”
Hanson thinks that the media has accumulated more than enough attention about deportation through the Jackie Tran case, an alleged gang member who has been fighting his deportation for years now.
“It has allowed for public debate so people can see for themselves the frustrations we see," he said. "It has allowed people to formulate their own opinions; it is not just police beating the drum."
In 2002, Younn survived a mall shooting, but a bullet ended up lodged in his spine, causing paralysis in his leg and bowel problems. During this incidence, FK member Linju Ly was said to be the driver of the car, and Michael Oduneye the gunman.
Six days later, Ly was gunned down.
Over the years, time and resources have been spent on monitoring Younn while he has been residing in the community. Younn was convicted in 2005 of weapons-related offences while Cardona had convictions of drug-relations.
I believe Nadia, once again, did a great job on getting the story out. The article does allow for an opinion to form but I believe that there is no bias set up in this story. This story is very relevant to our blog, and it’s proximity.
It raises issues that many Calgarians’ probably do not think about, and raises the awareness on this topic. It shows the dark side and the bright side of deportation, something that the public should be more aware and concerned about. This story is compelling, and I’m sure it is going to the get attention that it deserves.
N.Moharib (November 13, 2009) Two Alberta criminals deported [Electronic Version] Calgary Sun
By James Wilt
On November 11th, 2009, the Calgary Herald published an article titled ‘Downturn helps unmask mortgage fraud in Alberta’, with the byline of ‘Reports ‘tip of the iceberg,’ says detective’. Authored by Calgary Herald reporter Stephane Massinon (who also wrote the article I analyzed on October 24th, 2009), the article outlined the results of a recent investigation conducted by the Alberta Mortgage Fraud Symposium regarding the increasing amount of mortgage fraud, which is frequently tied to drug grow operations and organized crime (or gangs).
The results of the study indicated that the problem is on the rise, which was affirmed by the quote contributed by a detective in the economic crimes unit of the Calgary Police Force: "We are getting numerous reports coming in; I think it's just the tip of the iceberg". To validate the leading claim, Massinon utilized quotes from a detective in the economic crimes unit of the CPS, a Calgary-based RCMP Sergeant, and Scotiabank’s manager of fraud protection. In addition, Massinon detailed the procedure through which perpetrators commit mortgage fraud, and how the problem is affecting the housing market as a whole.
From an analytical perspective, Stephane Massinon’s article was excellently constructed and written. The reporter managed to maintain an extremely objective, fact-based point of view, and provided the reader an abundant amount of information (which consisted of quotes and situation details) to completely understand the issue.
One of the more impressive elements of the articles was the fact that Massinon provided the reasons, current situation, and potential complications in solving the issue, which gave the layman reader an all rounded concept of the escalating problem. The only improvement that Massinon could make would be to include quantitative data through the means of statistics or graphs, which would increase the ability for the reader to grasp the content.
In conclusion, Massionon’s news article was a very good report on the current problems in Alberta regarding mortgage fraud and organized gang involvement. He successfully maintained objectivity throughout the entire piece, which resulted in the effective communication of the information. As stated, the one improvement that could be made would be to include quantitative information.
Massinon, S. (2009, November 11). Downturn helps unmask mortgage fraud in Alberta [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
On November 11th, 2009, the Calgary Herald published an article titled ‘Downturn helps unmask mortgage fraud in Alberta’, with the byline of ‘Reports ‘tip of the iceberg,’ says detective’. Authored by Calgary Herald reporter Stephane Massinon (who also wrote the article I analyzed on October 24th, 2009), the article outlined the results of a recent investigation conducted by the Alberta Mortgage Fraud Symposium regarding the increasing amount of mortgage fraud, which is frequently tied to drug grow operations and organized crime (or gangs).
The results of the study indicated that the problem is on the rise, which was affirmed by the quote contributed by a detective in the economic crimes unit of the Calgary Police Force: "We are getting numerous reports coming in; I think it's just the tip of the iceberg". To validate the leading claim, Massinon utilized quotes from a detective in the economic crimes unit of the CPS, a Calgary-based RCMP Sergeant, and Scotiabank’s manager of fraud protection. In addition, Massinon detailed the procedure through which perpetrators commit mortgage fraud, and how the problem is affecting the housing market as a whole.
From an analytical perspective, Stephane Massinon’s article was excellently constructed and written. The reporter managed to maintain an extremely objective, fact-based point of view, and provided the reader an abundant amount of information (which consisted of quotes and situation details) to completely understand the issue.
One of the more impressive elements of the articles was the fact that Massinon provided the reasons, current situation, and potential complications in solving the issue, which gave the layman reader an all rounded concept of the escalating problem. The only improvement that Massinon could make would be to include quantitative data through the means of statistics or graphs, which would increase the ability for the reader to grasp the content.
In conclusion, Massionon’s news article was a very good report on the current problems in Alberta regarding mortgage fraud and organized gang involvement. He successfully maintained objectivity throughout the entire piece, which resulted in the effective communication of the information. As stated, the one improvement that could be made would be to include quantitative information.
Massinon, S. (2009, November 11). Downturn helps unmask mortgage fraud in Alberta [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
Calgary Gang Member Deported
By Nicolle Amyotte
In an article penned by Sherri Zickefoose, the fact that a Calgary gangster has been deported is stated, specifically Jason Youn being deported to Korea. Youn, according to the article, belonged to the Fresh off the Boat (FOB) Killers gang, and was convicted in 2005 of serious weapons-related offenses.
The story of Youn being shot and nearly killed inside of Southcentre mall by a passenger of a vehicle being driven by Linju Ly, a rival gang member, is highlighted. Ly’s death came just weeks later while he shoveled his sidewalk. The article does not state that the death was Youn’s doing, but implies it by not labeling the blame anywhere else.
Police chief Rick Hanson is quoted in this article, as he is in many that I have blogged, giving the article a very palpable credibility. He claims that this is one individual we will not have to worry about anymore, and points out the question of whether or not taking four years to deport this individual was effective enough, and whether or not the police are effective enough against gang violence. Mr. Hanson seems to believe that they are.
An interesting addition to the article was the mention of another gang member being deported this week, from the Medicine Hat area. Although this isn’t incredibly relevant to Calgary controls of gang activity, it is interesting to note that the surrounding area is also seeing better protection.
A comment made on the online version by an individual posting as “Celeste” is another point of interest, the individual’s view is that because many gang members were raised here and should not be sent away from a society that breeds them to be the way they have become. Several snide comments follow Celeste’s expression of her views. Calgarians, it can therefore be viewed, do not like the idea that we are even partially to blame for the actions of these individuals.
Zickefoose, S. (November 13, 2009). Calgary gang member deported. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 17, 2009 from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Calgary+gang+member+deported/2217015/story.html
In an article penned by Sherri Zickefoose, the fact that a Calgary gangster has been deported is stated, specifically Jason Youn being deported to Korea. Youn, according to the article, belonged to the Fresh off the Boat (FOB) Killers gang, and was convicted in 2005 of serious weapons-related offenses.
The story of Youn being shot and nearly killed inside of Southcentre mall by a passenger of a vehicle being driven by Linju Ly, a rival gang member, is highlighted. Ly’s death came just weeks later while he shoveled his sidewalk. The article does not state that the death was Youn’s doing, but implies it by not labeling the blame anywhere else.
Police chief Rick Hanson is quoted in this article, as he is in many that I have blogged, giving the article a very palpable credibility. He claims that this is one individual we will not have to worry about anymore, and points out the question of whether or not taking four years to deport this individual was effective enough, and whether or not the police are effective enough against gang violence. Mr. Hanson seems to believe that they are.
An interesting addition to the article was the mention of another gang member being deported this week, from the Medicine Hat area. Although this isn’t incredibly relevant to Calgary controls of gang activity, it is interesting to note that the surrounding area is also seeing better protection.
A comment made on the online version by an individual posting as “Celeste” is another point of interest, the individual’s view is that because many gang members were raised here and should not be sent away from a society that breeds them to be the way they have become. Several snide comments follow Celeste’s expression of her views. Calgarians, it can therefore be viewed, do not like the idea that we are even partially to blame for the actions of these individuals.
Zickefoose, S. (November 13, 2009). Calgary gang member deported. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 17, 2009 from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Calgary+gang+member+deported/2217015/story.html
By Megan Eichhorn
On November 10, 2009, Calgary Herald's Daryl Slade reported Justice Allen Sulatycky's guilty verdict for drug-dealer, Travis Brunet. Sulatycky said that gang members must be a sent a message to stop their use of guns.
Brunet claimed that he was too intoxicated to form the intent to kill and was only trying to scare his victim when the gun accidentally went off. Brunet got a life sentence for second-degree murder. Sulatycky says this will send a message that carrying a gun and killing someone, whether it is an accident or not, will result in jail time.
Facts in this article were based on quotes from the judge and the shooting victim's mother, as well as dates, locations and what was probably said at the court hearing. This article is biased in that it only includes quotes from people who view Brunet as guilty. When Slade reports Brunet's story, it is followed by the judge's conclusion that it is false. The questions of who, what, where, when and why are all thoroughly answered in this article.
Slade's article is more evidence of journalistic support of crime-fighting. Again, this makes sense because the readers of the Calgary Herald are citizens in this city and are likely interested in safety.
Slade, D. (2009, November 10). Drug dealer found guilty in C-train station murder. Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Drug+dealer+found+guilty+train+station+murder/2205268/story.html
On November 10, 2009, Calgary Herald's Daryl Slade reported Justice Allen Sulatycky's guilty verdict for drug-dealer, Travis Brunet. Sulatycky said that gang members must be a sent a message to stop their use of guns.
Brunet claimed that he was too intoxicated to form the intent to kill and was only trying to scare his victim when the gun accidentally went off. Brunet got a life sentence for second-degree murder. Sulatycky says this will send a message that carrying a gun and killing someone, whether it is an accident or not, will result in jail time.
Facts in this article were based on quotes from the judge and the shooting victim's mother, as well as dates, locations and what was probably said at the court hearing. This article is biased in that it only includes quotes from people who view Brunet as guilty. When Slade reports Brunet's story, it is followed by the judge's conclusion that it is false. The questions of who, what, where, when and why are all thoroughly answered in this article.
Slade's article is more evidence of journalistic support of crime-fighting. Again, this makes sense because the readers of the Calgary Herald are citizens in this city and are likely interested in safety.
Slade, D. (2009, November 10). Drug dealer found guilty in C-train station murder. Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Drug+dealer+found+guilty+train+station+murder/2205268/story.html
Friday, November 13, 2009
By Megan Eichhorn
On November 10, 2009, Calgary Herald's, Daryl Slade, reported Justice Allen Sulatycky's guilty verdict for drug-dealer Travis Brunet. Sulatycky said that gang members must be a sent a message to stop their use of guns. Brunet claimed that he was too intoxicated to form the intent to kill and was only trying to scare his victim when the gun accidentally went off.
Brunet got a life sentence for second-degree murder. Sulatycky says this will send a message that carrying a gun and killing someone, whether it is an accident or not, will result in jail time.
Facts in this article were based on quotes from the judge and the shooting victim's mother, as well as dates, locations and what was probably said at the court hearing. This article is biased in that it only includes quotes from people who view Brunet as guilty. When Slade reports Brunet's story, it is followed by the judge's conclusion that it is false. The questions of who, what, where, when and why are all thoroughly answered in this article.
Slade's article is more evidence of journalistic support of crime-fighting. Again, this makes sense because the readers of the Calgary Herald are citizens in this city and are likely interested in safety.
Slade, D. (2009, November 10). Drug dealer found guilty in C-train station murder. Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Drug+dealer+found+guilty+train+station+murder/2205268/story.html
On November 10, 2009, Calgary Herald's, Daryl Slade, reported Justice Allen Sulatycky's guilty verdict for drug-dealer Travis Brunet. Sulatycky said that gang members must be a sent a message to stop their use of guns. Brunet claimed that he was too intoxicated to form the intent to kill and was only trying to scare his victim when the gun accidentally went off.
Brunet got a life sentence for second-degree murder. Sulatycky says this will send a message that carrying a gun and killing someone, whether it is an accident or not, will result in jail time.
Facts in this article were based on quotes from the judge and the shooting victim's mother, as well as dates, locations and what was probably said at the court hearing. This article is biased in that it only includes quotes from people who view Brunet as guilty. When Slade reports Brunet's story, it is followed by the judge's conclusion that it is false. The questions of who, what, where, when and why are all thoroughly answered in this article.
Slade's article is more evidence of journalistic support of crime-fighting. Again, this makes sense because the readers of the Calgary Herald are citizens in this city and are likely interested in safety.
Slade, D. (2009, November 10). Drug dealer found guilty in C-train station murder. Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Drug+dealer+found+guilty+train+station+murder/2205268/story.html
Wednesday, November 11, 2009
Overworked and Understaffed: Too Many Organized Crime Cases leave RCMP Feeling Overwhelmed
By James Wilt
On November 2nd, 2009, the Calgary Herald released an article titled “Alberta RCMP strained by organized crime focus”. Authored by Jason Van Rassel, the extensive report summarized a recently obtained annual evaluation from the RCMP which indicated that the Alberta police force are becoming swamped by the amount of time and effort required to secure evidence from a crime due to an overload of cases combined with a overall understaffing.
Within the article, Van Rassel utilized numerous quotes from Chief Superintendent Dan Killam, an unnamed RCMP evaluator, and Athabasca assistant professor Carolyn Greene. In addition, Van Rassel presented statistics, which included the number of investigative referrals directed to Calgary since 2005, the monetary value of seized assets (including homes and vehicles), as well as the breakdown of RCMP members within the province. Due to the implementation of both quotes and statistics, one may conclude that Van Rassel successfully demonstrated the current situation in provincial law enforcement.
I believe that Van Rassel presented the information in an admiringly objective, fact-based manner, with very few problems. He clearly stated the reasoning behind the personnel deficit, and gave a complete comprehensive report. The only problem I had with the article was that because of the fact Van Rassel was covering such an extensive analysis his writing, at times, felt slightly disjointed. However, with such an amount of information, such a situation is understandable.
On a whole, Jason Van Rassel did an excellent job of reporting on the situation. He presented the facts in a news-like manner, and allowed the reader to gain a good understanding of the events.
Van Rassel, J. (2009, November 2). Alberta RCMP strained by organized crime focus [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
On November 2nd, 2009, the Calgary Herald released an article titled “Alberta RCMP strained by organized crime focus”. Authored by Jason Van Rassel, the extensive report summarized a recently obtained annual evaluation from the RCMP which indicated that the Alberta police force are becoming swamped by the amount of time and effort required to secure evidence from a crime due to an overload of cases combined with a overall understaffing.
Within the article, Van Rassel utilized numerous quotes from Chief Superintendent Dan Killam, an unnamed RCMP evaluator, and Athabasca assistant professor Carolyn Greene. In addition, Van Rassel presented statistics, which included the number of investigative referrals directed to Calgary since 2005, the monetary value of seized assets (including homes and vehicles), as well as the breakdown of RCMP members within the province. Due to the implementation of both quotes and statistics, one may conclude that Van Rassel successfully demonstrated the current situation in provincial law enforcement.
I believe that Van Rassel presented the information in an admiringly objective, fact-based manner, with very few problems. He clearly stated the reasoning behind the personnel deficit, and gave a complete comprehensive report. The only problem I had with the article was that because of the fact Van Rassel was covering such an extensive analysis his writing, at times, felt slightly disjointed. However, with such an amount of information, such a situation is understandable.
On a whole, Jason Van Rassel did an excellent job of reporting on the situation. He presented the facts in a news-like manner, and allowed the reader to gain a good understanding of the events.
Van Rassel, J. (2009, November 2). Alberta RCMP strained by organized crime focus [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
Gang Warfare Hits Hard
By Nicolle Amyotte
The story I selected this week, Gang warfare claims 50 lives, authored by Nadia Moharib of the Calgary Sun, speaks to the report last week on Calgary having the highest per capita gang violence rates in the country (see James’ blog entry last week). It is clearly an older version of this report, but I feel that it is still relevant, or even more relevant now than at the time of publishing.
Statistics are listed in the article, specifically the number of casualties, as result of gang activity as well as the number of non-fatal crimes committed between January 1, 2005 and September 9, 2009. In the article, police chief, Rick Hanson, describes the statistics as “Frightening”. The report released last week re-affirms this idea. I feel that having Rick Hanson speak to the press on this issue confirms that this is a definite problem, and one that the police would like to see change.
Sentences later state that the situation may worsen before improving- quoting deputy chief Murray Stooke. He also states that Calgary police do not believe that they have a solution for gang violence just yet, but have had an impact on calming it thus far. This, in addition to Hanson’s comments, is the opinion of the Calgary Police Service.
Countering this opinion, on the online version of the article, an anonymous comment was posted under the name, “Buddy”. He claims that there is too much of a public scare surrounding gang violence when it is simply a regular occurrence in any metropolitan city, as an attempt to get more funding from the province. There is quite clearly a contrast between the opinions of the writer of this article and the public, or “Buddy” at the very least. With the newest report, public opinion will likely only continue to grow in favor of Buddy.
Moharib, N. (September 17, 2009) Gang warfare claims 50 lives. The Calgary Sun. Retrieved November 9, 2009 from http://www.calgarysun.com/news/alberta/2009/09/17/10951246-sun.html
The story I selected this week, Gang warfare claims 50 lives, authored by Nadia Moharib of the Calgary Sun, speaks to the report last week on Calgary having the highest per capita gang violence rates in the country (see James’ blog entry last week). It is clearly an older version of this report, but I feel that it is still relevant, or even more relevant now than at the time of publishing.
Statistics are listed in the article, specifically the number of casualties, as result of gang activity as well as the number of non-fatal crimes committed between January 1, 2005 and September 9, 2009. In the article, police chief, Rick Hanson, describes the statistics as “Frightening”. The report released last week re-affirms this idea. I feel that having Rick Hanson speak to the press on this issue confirms that this is a definite problem, and one that the police would like to see change.
Sentences later state that the situation may worsen before improving- quoting deputy chief Murray Stooke. He also states that Calgary police do not believe that they have a solution for gang violence just yet, but have had an impact on calming it thus far. This, in addition to Hanson’s comments, is the opinion of the Calgary Police Service.
Countering this opinion, on the online version of the article, an anonymous comment was posted under the name, “Buddy”. He claims that there is too much of a public scare surrounding gang violence when it is simply a regular occurrence in any metropolitan city, as an attempt to get more funding from the province. There is quite clearly a contrast between the opinions of the writer of this article and the public, or “Buddy” at the very least. With the newest report, public opinion will likely only continue to grow in favor of Buddy.
Moharib, N. (September 17, 2009) Gang warfare claims 50 lives. The Calgary Sun. Retrieved November 9, 2009 from http://www.calgarysun.com/news/alberta/2009/09/17/10951246-sun.html
Saturday, November 7, 2009
By Megan Eichhorn
On October 31, 2009, the Calgary Herald reported that the first case heard in the Calgary Court Centre’s new high-security courtroom was a high-risk preliminary hearing for a gang-related shooting. The room features floor-to-ceiling Plexiglass. The alleged gang members on trial will face charges of attempted murder and weapon offences in relation to last year’s exchange of gunfire with a rival gang.
The article only quotes the lawyer of one of the men facing charges, but no one else involved in the case. Dates and locations are also stated, which could be considered facts. The article seems to emphasize the dangerous nature of these gangs by using the words “high-risk” and “high-security.” The mention of the extent of the plexiglass also accomplishes this.
This article continues in the same direction as the many previous pieces about what measures the city of Calgary is taking in relation to gangs. There seems to be many reports on this topic, which makes sense because it is a matter of public safety. Calgarians clearly want to know what the government is doing to protect citizens.
References
Four alleged Calgary gangsters to stand trial in high-risk courtoom. (2009, October 31). Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 5, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Four+alleged+Calgary+gangsters+stand+trial+high+risk+courtroom/2166344/story.html
On October 31, 2009, the Calgary Herald reported that the first case heard in the Calgary Court Centre’s new high-security courtroom was a high-risk preliminary hearing for a gang-related shooting. The room features floor-to-ceiling Plexiglass. The alleged gang members on trial will face charges of attempted murder and weapon offences in relation to last year’s exchange of gunfire with a rival gang.
The article only quotes the lawyer of one of the men facing charges, but no one else involved in the case. Dates and locations are also stated, which could be considered facts. The article seems to emphasize the dangerous nature of these gangs by using the words “high-risk” and “high-security.” The mention of the extent of the plexiglass also accomplishes this.
This article continues in the same direction as the many previous pieces about what measures the city of Calgary is taking in relation to gangs. There seems to be many reports on this topic, which makes sense because it is a matter of public safety. Calgarians clearly want to know what the government is doing to protect citizens.
References
Four alleged Calgary gangsters to stand trial in high-risk courtoom. (2009, October 31). Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 5, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Four+alleged+Calgary+gangsters+stand+trial+high+risk+courtroom/2166344/story.html
Thursday, November 5, 2009
By James Wilt
On October 30th, 2009, the Calgary Herald published an article titled, “Calgary's gang slayings tops in nation in 2008” that summated the shocking results of a recent statistical study reporting that Calgary has now moved into the position of leading Canadian cities in regard to gang-related slayings.
Within the article, the author, Gwendolyn Richards, included numerous statistics from the study (which was performed in 2008) as well as quotes from the Calgary Deputy Chief of police, a gang expert, and a Mount Royal University criminologist to support the claim. In addition, the author included a quote from the report that stated the increase in homicide total in Canada was
"almost entirely to increases in Alberta and British Columbia, much of which was gang-related"
as well as a graph indicating the results of the gang-related homicides per 100,000 people within each respective major city.
Although the article was very intriguing (as well as being very relevant to the Calgary read), upon further investigation it appears that the statistics were slightly twisted in order to create the compelling story.
The title states that Calgary “leads [Canada] in gang-related slayings”, when the article stated later that “The Toronto area recorded 24 gang-related homicides”. The reason is discussed in the following sentence, which described the study accounted for population.
Another similar fault is discovered in the presented graph, where it shows both Vancouver and Montreal had more gang-related homicides (19 and 17 respectively), but due to the fact Calgary had more such murders per 100,000 people, it came first.
Although it is difficult to understand why the author would make the facts appear differently than it they actually were, it would be extremely simple to remedy.
Rather than claiming that Calgary leads the country in gang-related homicides, they could truthfully present the facts as Calgary leading the country in gang-related homicides per 100,000 citizens. As soon as such a change was made, the graph would become a legit presentation of the statistics.
Asides from the misleading title, I believe the article was an objective, factual representation of the study. The Richards did an excellent job of providing the reader multiple perspectives (which included quotes, statistics, analysis, and the brief story of a gang victim) and presented the reader a very detailed and accurate understanding of the situation.
In conclusion, asides from the misleading title, I believe the author did an excellent job of collecting information and presenting it effectively and compellingly.
Richards, G. (2009, October 30). Calgary's gang slayings tops in nation in 2008 [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
On October 30th, 2009, the Calgary Herald published an article titled, “Calgary's gang slayings tops in nation in 2008” that summated the shocking results of a recent statistical study reporting that Calgary has now moved into the position of leading Canadian cities in regard to gang-related slayings.
Within the article, the author, Gwendolyn Richards, included numerous statistics from the study (which was performed in 2008) as well as quotes from the Calgary Deputy Chief of police, a gang expert, and a Mount Royal University criminologist to support the claim. In addition, the author included a quote from the report that stated the increase in homicide total in Canada was
"almost entirely to increases in Alberta and British Columbia, much of which was gang-related"
as well as a graph indicating the results of the gang-related homicides per 100,000 people within each respective major city.
Although the article was very intriguing (as well as being very relevant to the Calgary read), upon further investigation it appears that the statistics were slightly twisted in order to create the compelling story.
The title states that Calgary “leads [Canada] in gang-related slayings”, when the article stated later that “The Toronto area recorded 24 gang-related homicides”. The reason is discussed in the following sentence, which described the study accounted for population.
Another similar fault is discovered in the presented graph, where it shows both Vancouver and Montreal had more gang-related homicides (19 and 17 respectively), but due to the fact Calgary had more such murders per 100,000 people, it came first.
Although it is difficult to understand why the author would make the facts appear differently than it they actually were, it would be extremely simple to remedy.
Rather than claiming that Calgary leads the country in gang-related homicides, they could truthfully present the facts as Calgary leading the country in gang-related homicides per 100,000 citizens. As soon as such a change was made, the graph would become a legit presentation of the statistics.
Asides from the misleading title, I believe the article was an objective, factual representation of the study. The Richards did an excellent job of providing the reader multiple perspectives (which included quotes, statistics, analysis, and the brief story of a gang victim) and presented the reader a very detailed and accurate understanding of the situation.
In conclusion, asides from the misleading title, I believe the author did an excellent job of collecting information and presenting it effectively and compellingly.
Richards, G. (2009, October 30). Calgary's gang slayings tops in nation in 2008 [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
Hearing Set for Men Involved in Calgary Restaurant Triple-Shooting
By Kelsey Andersen
On April 19, 2010, three of four men will face their two week preliminary hearing regarding the triple homicide that happened at the Bolsa Restaurant on New Years of 2009.
The date was set by provincial Judg,e Les Grieve, on Thursday for the three men charged. Nicholas Rodrigo Hovansian, 24; Nathan Zuccherato, 23; and Michael Joseph Roberto, 25 are all facing three counts of first-degree murder.
The gang related shootings claimed three victims, Sanjeev Mann, Aaron Bendle and bystander Keni Su'a.
Shane Parker, crown prosecutor, claims that Zuccherato and Roberto will join before the spring hearing along with Hovanesian, who was arrested early October in Lethbridge.
Christian Honorio, age 25, also faces charges related to the gang-related killings, along with three first-degree murder charges. He is scheduled to be in court November 19, 2009, and his preliminary hearing will most likely be set at the November court appearance.
Investigators have reason to believe that victims Mann, 22, and Bendle, 22, were targeted because of a gang feud that has been linked to at least 25 homicides in recent years.
Su'a, 43, was a bystander who fled Bolsa Restaurant when the shots began. Su'a was met by a third gunman outside who gunned him down, according to police investigations.
I believe that this article is very compelling. It's short, sweet, and gets right to the point. All the articles that I have used, once again, show no room for opinions at all. They all seem to be very fact-based. It would have made it more legit if the article could have used some quotes.
I also think that we will be hearing a lot more about this trial coming up because it was big news back in early 2009 and people are interested in hearing what is going to happen.
We should be hearing more about this after the November 19, 2009 preliminary trial happens. Also, we should be hearing a lot more news after the other 3 convicted men have reached their preliminary hearing date.
Calgary Herald. 2009. Trial dates set in fatal Calgary restaurant triple-shooting. The Calgary Herald.Retrieved on on November 1, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Trial+dates+fatal+Calgary+restaurant+triple+shooting/2161722/story.html
On April 19, 2010, three of four men will face their two week preliminary hearing regarding the triple homicide that happened at the Bolsa Restaurant on New Years of 2009.
The date was set by provincial Judg,e Les Grieve, on Thursday for the three men charged. Nicholas Rodrigo Hovansian, 24; Nathan Zuccherato, 23; and Michael Joseph Roberto, 25 are all facing three counts of first-degree murder.
The gang related shootings claimed three victims, Sanjeev Mann, Aaron Bendle and bystander Keni Su'a.
Shane Parker, crown prosecutor, claims that Zuccherato and Roberto will join before the spring hearing along with Hovanesian, who was arrested early October in Lethbridge.
Christian Honorio, age 25, also faces charges related to the gang-related killings, along with three first-degree murder charges. He is scheduled to be in court November 19, 2009, and his preliminary hearing will most likely be set at the November court appearance.
Investigators have reason to believe that victims Mann, 22, and Bendle, 22, were targeted because of a gang feud that has been linked to at least 25 homicides in recent years.
Su'a, 43, was a bystander who fled Bolsa Restaurant when the shots began. Su'a was met by a third gunman outside who gunned him down, according to police investigations.
I believe that this article is very compelling. It's short, sweet, and gets right to the point. All the articles that I have used, once again, show no room for opinions at all. They all seem to be very fact-based. It would have made it more legit if the article could have used some quotes.
I also think that we will be hearing a lot more about this trial coming up because it was big news back in early 2009 and people are interested in hearing what is going to happen.
We should be hearing more about this after the November 19, 2009 preliminary trial happens. Also, we should be hearing a lot more news after the other 3 convicted men have reached their preliminary hearing date.
Calgary Herald. 2009. Trial dates set in fatal Calgary restaurant triple-shooting. The Calgary Herald.Retrieved on on November 1, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Trial+dates+fatal+Calgary+restaurant+triple+shooting/2161722/story.html
Fourth Man Charged in Gang-Related Calgary Weapon Seizure
By Nicolle Amyotte
This story is likely intended to encourage Calgarians to show that the police force is doing a competent job of protecting our city. It is a very brief article, but I feel that this message is evident.
Once again, this article is not particularly opinionated but still valuable. On the online version, two comments from anonymous sources were posted as well. One of them was not particularly valuable, but the other expressed a legitimate concern- the possibility of weapons being brought into the city even after the seizing takes place.
The article by Chiang was written to inform readers of a fourth member being charged in a discovery earlier this year, specifically in April, of a large amount of weapons seized in Carburn Park.
Five men were reported acting suspiciously, and as of Sunday, four have been captured. While it has taken months for these individuals to be caught (two were exposed as culprits last month), the fact of the matter is that the police have made eventual arrests in the case. The city should feel secure, the article suggests.
Chiang, C. (November 3, 2009) Fourth man charged in gang-related Calgary weapons seizure. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 3, 2009 from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Fourth+charged+weapons+seizure/2178078/story.html.
This story is likely intended to encourage Calgarians to show that the police force is doing a competent job of protecting our city. It is a very brief article, but I feel that this message is evident.
Once again, this article is not particularly opinionated but still valuable. On the online version, two comments from anonymous sources were posted as well. One of them was not particularly valuable, but the other expressed a legitimate concern- the possibility of weapons being brought into the city even after the seizing takes place.
The article by Chiang was written to inform readers of a fourth member being charged in a discovery earlier this year, specifically in April, of a large amount of weapons seized in Carburn Park.
Five men were reported acting suspiciously, and as of Sunday, four have been captured. While it has taken months for these individuals to be caught (two were exposed as culprits last month), the fact of the matter is that the police have made eventual arrests in the case. The city should feel secure, the article suggests.
Chiang, C. (November 3, 2009) Fourth man charged in gang-related Calgary weapons seizure. The Calgary Herald. Retrieved November 3, 2009 from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Fourth+charged+weapons+seizure/2178078/story.html.
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
By Kelsey Andersen
Health care professionals face yet another new challenge. Bill 46, the Gunshot and Stab Wound Mandatory Disclosure Act, which proposes that health professionals must report patients with gun shots or stab wounds. This new bill went back for proposal on October 26, 2009.The bill is being put into legislation to make it easier for health officials and law enforcement to communicate faster and easier.
There are many arguments to this bill, for and against. There is the argument that it makes communication safer and easier but critics claim that it could be invading on civil liberties.
Liberal opposition Leader, David Swann, does not have much faith in the proposition of Bill 46. He explains that the bill does not have an appropriate balance between patient privacy and police investigation...
"It's a very delicate balance between confidentiality and trust between a doctor and a patient, which could be very seriously jeopardized if physicians are required to report cases, which may or may not have any criminal association with them...I think we need to have a very serious discussion...This this kind of a bill is going to suppress people coming to health-care attention."
The proposed bill would require health workers to provide law enforcement with the patients name, if treatment was given, location of treatment, or if the patient is not hospitalized, the location that the patient was seen by paramedics.
“Health-care professionals can report. There’s nothing that’s stopping them... (but) different hospitals have different ways to deal with it,”, said Solicitor-General and Public Security Ministry spokeswoman Sharon Lopatka. “What this does is make it mandatory and very clear when they need to disclose, and it provides police with important information on public safety by preventing further violence of injury,” claimed Lopatka.
Bill 46 excludes the reporting of self-inflicted or accidental injuries.
I believe that the article was very fact-based. It did not show any room for opinion what so ever. It was written by Tarina White. The article sums up how the Bill will affect Canadians and raises awareness about what privacy issues may be intruded.
White, T. (October 25, 2009) Wound disclosure bill comes back. Calgary Sun. Retrieved from the internet on October 26, 2009 from http://www.edmontonsun.com/news/alberta/2009/10/25/11519061-sun.html
Health care professionals face yet another new challenge. Bill 46, the Gunshot and Stab Wound Mandatory Disclosure Act, which proposes that health professionals must report patients with gun shots or stab wounds. This new bill went back for proposal on October 26, 2009.The bill is being put into legislation to make it easier for health officials and law enforcement to communicate faster and easier.
There are many arguments to this bill, for and against. There is the argument that it makes communication safer and easier but critics claim that it could be invading on civil liberties.
Liberal opposition Leader, David Swann, does not have much faith in the proposition of Bill 46. He explains that the bill does not have an appropriate balance between patient privacy and police investigation...
"It's a very delicate balance between confidentiality and trust between a doctor and a patient, which could be very seriously jeopardized if physicians are required to report cases, which may or may not have any criminal association with them...I think we need to have a very serious discussion...This this kind of a bill is going to suppress people coming to health-care attention."
The proposed bill would require health workers to provide law enforcement with the patients name, if treatment was given, location of treatment, or if the patient is not hospitalized, the location that the patient was seen by paramedics.
“Health-care professionals can report. There’s nothing that’s stopping them... (but) different hospitals have different ways to deal with it,”, said Solicitor-General and Public Security Ministry spokeswoman Sharon Lopatka. “What this does is make it mandatory and very clear when they need to disclose, and it provides police with important information on public safety by preventing further violence of injury,” claimed Lopatka.
Bill 46 excludes the reporting of self-inflicted or accidental injuries.
I believe that the article was very fact-based. It did not show any room for opinion what so ever. It was written by Tarina White. The article sums up how the Bill will affect Canadians and raises awareness about what privacy issues may be intruded.
White, T. (October 25, 2009) Wound disclosure bill comes back. Calgary Sun. Retrieved from the internet on October 26, 2009 from http://www.edmontonsun.com/news/alberta/2009/10/25/11519061-sun.html
By Nicolle Amyotte
...Since Bill 46, the Gunshot and Stab Wound Mandatory Disclosure Act, is a brand new policy, there are currently not too many opinion pieces about it out there. I still felt that it needed to be addressed in my blog however, and also felt that journalist, Gwendolyn Richards, did an excellent job in regards to her piece written about the Bill in the Calgary Herald on October 26, 2009. It is not an incredibly opinionated article, but I thought it worthy of blogging about for my purposes...
The bill being proposed would force health care workers to report any stab or gunshot wounds, rather than leaving the information at the discretion of physicians and nurses. Exceptions would be for an accidental or self-inflicted wound. John Dooks, head of Calgary’s police association, says this will serve to protect both victims as well as health-care professionals.
Furthermore, John Dooks elaborated on a strategy that some gang members employ in rivalry- to attack a family member of an opposing gang member and wait at the hospital for their intended victim. With disclosure becoming necessary, security would be heightened around gang affiliates, and the risk of an in-hospital attack would be greatly decreased.
With the evidence given, it seems the opinion of Richards, or of the Calgary Herald, is that the new legislation is a great idea. Opposing viewpoints may include the argument that more gang affiliates would choose not to report their injuries for fear of their identity giving them away.
Another aspect of Bill 46 was that an injured person receiving treatment out of a hospital would have their location disclosed and one might argue that this is something gang associates would fear as well. Another is the potential for a breach of doctor-patient confidentiality to become the norm. It is allowable in this case, so who's to say that it could not go any further?
Richards, G.(October 26, 2009). Police welcome proposed bill 46. The Calgary Herald. Retreieved October 27, 2009 from http://www2.canada.com/calgaryherald/news/city/story.html?id=71b0e8b7-8fb3-4d02-a1b2-2d25e83ee68b
...Since Bill 46, the Gunshot and Stab Wound Mandatory Disclosure Act, is a brand new policy, there are currently not too many opinion pieces about it out there. I still felt that it needed to be addressed in my blog however, and also felt that journalist, Gwendolyn Richards, did an excellent job in regards to her piece written about the Bill in the Calgary Herald on October 26, 2009. It is not an incredibly opinionated article, but I thought it worthy of blogging about for my purposes...
The bill being proposed would force health care workers to report any stab or gunshot wounds, rather than leaving the information at the discretion of physicians and nurses. Exceptions would be for an accidental or self-inflicted wound. John Dooks, head of Calgary’s police association, says this will serve to protect both victims as well as health-care professionals.
Furthermore, John Dooks elaborated on a strategy that some gang members employ in rivalry- to attack a family member of an opposing gang member and wait at the hospital for their intended victim. With disclosure becoming necessary, security would be heightened around gang affiliates, and the risk of an in-hospital attack would be greatly decreased.
With the evidence given, it seems the opinion of Richards, or of the Calgary Herald, is that the new legislation is a great idea. Opposing viewpoints may include the argument that more gang affiliates would choose not to report their injuries for fear of their identity giving them away.
Another aspect of Bill 46 was that an injured person receiving treatment out of a hospital would have their location disclosed and one might argue that this is something gang associates would fear as well. Another is the potential for a breach of doctor-patient confidentiality to become the norm. It is allowable in this case, so who's to say that it could not go any further?
Richards, G.(October 26, 2009). Police welcome proposed bill 46. The Calgary Herald. Retreieved October 27, 2009 from http://www2.canada.com/calgaryherald/news/city/story.html?id=71b0e8b7-8fb3-4d02-a1b2-2d25e83ee68b
By James Wilt
On October 24th, 2009 the Calgary Herald published an article titled, ‘Calgary gang arrests trim murder tally, say police’, which was written by Herald reporter, Stephane Massinon. The article was sparked by the recent arrest of two alleged gang members who have been charged with multiple weapons offences. However, it seemed the primary focus of the article was the presentation of the opinion of Detective Gord Eiriksson, who believes that the increased number of gang arrests this year is resulting in considerably less gang activity in Calgary.
A compelling quote that Massinon used, which basically summarized the point of the article was:
“We've had so many people arrested this year or placed in jail, and since that's happened, we haven't had a gang homicide. I think that speaks volumes.”
Asides from the four quotes from Detective Eiriksson, Massinon also included various statistics and facts that described the previously mentioned arrests, as well as city-wide gang violence.
On a whole, Massinon’s article was extremely fact-based. As mentioned, she utilized many quotes and statistics, which added considerably to the believability and credibility of the news. However, the only person that Massinon quoted was Detective Eiriksson, which led to a very one-sided report. Such bias towards the law enforcement seems to be a trend whenever the media reports on crime related news, which could easily be countered with an increased number of sources.
On another note, it seemed that Massinon jumped between two different stories, which led to confusion. The first story was that of the two recently arrested people, including their history and current legal status.
The second story seemed to be the claim that increased arrests and detainment of gang members has led to reduced gang violence, which although compelling is somewhat distinct in regards to the initial story. I can understand the utilization of the arrests as a case study of sorts to support the detectives claim, but the manner in which Massinon seemed to suggest that both stories held equal importance within the report. A simple solution (which due to deadlines is difficult) would be to separate the news into two separate stories, which would lead to a much easier read for the layman reader.
Despite such criticism, I believe that Massinon did a fairly good job of presenting the news in a fairly objective manner. Although there were essentially two stories within the article, both were written factually and accurately.
Massinon, S. (2009, October 24). Calgary gang arrests trim murder tally, say police [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
On October 24th, 2009 the Calgary Herald published an article titled, ‘Calgary gang arrests trim murder tally, say police’, which was written by Herald reporter, Stephane Massinon. The article was sparked by the recent arrest of two alleged gang members who have been charged with multiple weapons offences. However, it seemed the primary focus of the article was the presentation of the opinion of Detective Gord Eiriksson, who believes that the increased number of gang arrests this year is resulting in considerably less gang activity in Calgary.
A compelling quote that Massinon used, which basically summarized the point of the article was:
“We've had so many people arrested this year or placed in jail, and since that's happened, we haven't had a gang homicide. I think that speaks volumes.”
Asides from the four quotes from Detective Eiriksson, Massinon also included various statistics and facts that described the previously mentioned arrests, as well as city-wide gang violence.
On a whole, Massinon’s article was extremely fact-based. As mentioned, she utilized many quotes and statistics, which added considerably to the believability and credibility of the news. However, the only person that Massinon quoted was Detective Eiriksson, which led to a very one-sided report. Such bias towards the law enforcement seems to be a trend whenever the media reports on crime related news, which could easily be countered with an increased number of sources.
On another note, it seemed that Massinon jumped between two different stories, which led to confusion. The first story was that of the two recently arrested people, including their history and current legal status.
The second story seemed to be the claim that increased arrests and detainment of gang members has led to reduced gang violence, which although compelling is somewhat distinct in regards to the initial story. I can understand the utilization of the arrests as a case study of sorts to support the detectives claim, but the manner in which Massinon seemed to suggest that both stories held equal importance within the report. A simple solution (which due to deadlines is difficult) would be to separate the news into two separate stories, which would lead to a much easier read for the layman reader.
Despite such criticism, I believe that Massinon did a fairly good job of presenting the news in a fairly objective manner. Although there were essentially two stories within the article, both were written factually and accurately.
Massinon, S. (2009, October 24). Calgary gang arrests trim murder tally, say police [Electronic version]. Calgary Herald.
By Megan Eichhorn
On October 22, 2009 Markham Hislop of S.E. Calgary News wrote an article about the YARD (Youth At Risk Development) program that was created in August of this year. The federal government is working with Calgary police and Community and Neighbourhood Services to help kids between the ages of 10 and 17 who are in a gang or are at risk of joining one.
The government and police think that early intervention is the best way to prevent them from involvement in possible future gang activity. These kids are identified by risk factors including negative influences, poor parental supervision, substance abuse, detachment from the community, interaction with anti-social peers, low educational/employment potential and the need for recognition and belonging.
This article had no quotes or statistics, but it did have a number to call for more information about the program. It didn’t necessarily need quotes or statistics, however, because Hislop mostly just stated characteristics of the YARD program, which seemed to be the most important aspect of the piece. There was no information about the rise or effect of gangs in Calgary, but in conjunction with other current events, the reader can probably assume that the program will be helpful.
With all the other news about gang member arrests and other things the police are doing in relation to gangs, it is clear that this is still an issue. The people of Calgary are concerned with safety, so the government and police force will probably continue to work together. News of more social programs may be reported, as well as the success or failure of these programs.
Hislop, M. (2009, October 22). YARD (Youth At Risk Development) program. S.E. Calgary News. Retrieved October 27, 2009, from http://www.secalgarynews.com/politics/aldermen/yard-youth-at-risk-development-program/
On October 22, 2009 Markham Hislop of S.E. Calgary News wrote an article about the YARD (Youth At Risk Development) program that was created in August of this year. The federal government is working with Calgary police and Community and Neighbourhood Services to help kids between the ages of 10 and 17 who are in a gang or are at risk of joining one.
The government and police think that early intervention is the best way to prevent them from involvement in possible future gang activity. These kids are identified by risk factors including negative influences, poor parental supervision, substance abuse, detachment from the community, interaction with anti-social peers, low educational/employment potential and the need for recognition and belonging.
This article had no quotes or statistics, but it did have a number to call for more information about the program. It didn’t necessarily need quotes or statistics, however, because Hislop mostly just stated characteristics of the YARD program, which seemed to be the most important aspect of the piece. There was no information about the rise or effect of gangs in Calgary, but in conjunction with other current events, the reader can probably assume that the program will be helpful.
With all the other news about gang member arrests and other things the police are doing in relation to gangs, it is clear that this is still an issue. The people of Calgary are concerned with safety, so the government and police force will probably continue to work together. News of more social programs may be reported, as well as the success or failure of these programs.
Hislop, M. (2009, October 22). YARD (Youth At Risk Development) program. S.E. Calgary News. Retrieved October 27, 2009, from http://www.secalgarynews.com/politics/aldermen/yard-youth-at-risk-development-program/
Thursday, October 22, 2009
By Megan Eichhorn
On October 9, 2009, the Calgary Sun’s Nadia Moharib reported that suspected gang member Alex Soza was arrested by the Fugitive Apprehension Detail at a high-risk traffic stop. Sgt. Tony Manning said that Soza was not disguised but was hiding from police due to a drug-related shooting in Lethbridge that has led to multiple assault and robbery charges. The shooting was in February of this year and Soza was arrested and charged about a month later. Calgary’s Fugitive Apprehension Detail unit has been at work for about a year-and-a-half, during which they have caught many of criminals. The unit seeks criminals who are dangerous, avoiding the police and have an active warrant. Moharib’s article did not use specific statistics, but rather generalized the number of people arrested by the Fugitive Apprehension Details unit. She quoted Manning, who could be considered an expert since he is a police sergeant. Although most of the article is about Soza, the conclusion is about the success of the unit. Again, the media is supporting the police force in Calgary and emphasizing facts that suggest they are doing a good job. Thus, Soza’s story is being shown as an example of this success. Clearly, the media is in favour of the police. There seems to be a tendency towards reports on gang-related incidents and how the city is addressing and solving the issue, but there is not much about the difficulties they are having. It is likely that more articles promoting their successes and advocating for more officers will be written.
Moharib, N. (2009, October 9). Police collar suspected gang fugitive. Calgary Sun. Retrieved October 19, 2009, from http://www.calgarysun.com/news/alberta/2009/10/09/11352571-sun.htm
Nine Alberta Men Charged in 1.5 Million Dollar Cocaine Bust
By Dara Defreitas
On October 21st 2009, Michelle Butterfield released an article in the Calgary Herald informing readers that five Calgary men and four Red Deer men had been charged with the trafficking of vast quantities of Cocaine. Butterfield mentioned that a total of eleven kilograms of Cocaine was found, and that the nine arrested supplied the drug to street gangs and criminal organisations all across Alberta. It was said the success of the capture of each man had come from an investigation that had been ongoing for a year by the Calgary Combined Special Forces Unit. No statistics were used, but Butterfield fully named each arrested man, stated their age, where they were from (Red Deer or Calgary), and specified how many charges each of them faced. She also explained that eleven kilograms of Cocaine was worth a 1.5 million dollars street value, which I felt was a good idea to mention because, to most readers, eleven kilograms doesn’t necessarily mean anything if they aren’t aware of the price that Cocaine costs, giving them a better understanding. Like the general conclusion drawn from my other Gangstar members, I think that this article has slight subjectivity to it because Butterfield chose to add the opinion of Inspector Kevin Forsen, who stated that the arrest of these men would impede activity of the gangs that were supplied with the Cocaine.
Butterfield, Michelle. (2009, October 21). Nine charged in cocaine trafficking bust. Calgary Herald. Retrieved October 21, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Nine+charged+cocaine+trafficking+bust/2129304/story.html
Dangerous Fugitive Arrested in Calgary
By Kelsey Andersen
Alex Soza was arrested earlier this week on multiple charges. He was pulled over in south-east Calgary with his daughter and girlfriend in the vehicle. Alex Soza’s daughter painfully watched her father get arrested by the Fugitive Apprehension Detail. Sgt. Tony Manning stated,
“We spent the better part of the week looking for him".
Soza’s active warrant has been out since February of this year after an aggravated assault charge in Lethbridge. Manning explains that the aggravated assault ended with a bullet in a mans leg. This situation was drug related. Not only being wanted in Lethbridge, Soza was said to be wanted out of breaches of Red Deer and Sylvan Lake area. Soza is also wanted for numerous counts of offences that include robbery, robbery with a fireman, and assault with a deadly weapon. Recognized as a dangerous fugitive, Soza has his next court appearance in Lethbridge October 26, 2009. The article is very fact-based, and has very reliable sources. It is definitely more news based rather than opinion. The article shows no room for an opinion to be formed. It was written by Nadia Moharib. The article practically sums up how dangerous the fugitive is, what the fugitive(Soza) has done, and when Soza is facing the courts.
References
N. Moharib (October 9, 2009)Calgary Sun. Police collar suspected gang fugitive, Retrieved October 13, 2009, from http://www.calgarysun.com/news/alberta/2009/10/09/11352571-sun.html
Gangs a Concern for Calgary Public, but Still Pleased With Police Efforts
By James Wilt
On October 15th of 2009, the Calgary Herald published an article in the City & Region section regarding the public opinion of the Calgary Police Service titled ‘Calgarians pleased with police service’, with the by-line ‘Gang violence remains a major concern’.
Authored by Gwendolyn Richards of the Herald, the article summarized a recently released survey conducted by the Calgary Police Commission Citizen Survey which reported that an overwhelming majority of Calgary citizens are satisfied with the service.
However, gang violence in Calgary is shown to be the area in which most Calgarians are concerned about, which CPC chairman Denis Painchaud primarily attributes to the New Year shootings which left 3 dead. Richards also quoted Painchaud as stating that
“there is still a significant gang problem out there...There’s still work to be done".
Following the mentioned concern with gang violence, the article proceeded to present more statistics and interview clips which suggested that although the public perception of safety is increasing, more officers will be needed as the city continues to grow in population.
I believe that Richards did a relatively good job of presenting the report in an objective, fact-based manner. In combination with the overwhelming amount of statistics, Richards included compelling interview clips with the mentioned chairman of the Calgary Police Commission, Alderman Diane Colley-Urquhart, and Deputy Chief Al Redford, which gave the article a good sense of validity and believability.
However, due to the fact the article was primarily in regards to the public perception of police presence, I believe it would have been beneficial if Richards had interviewed regular citizens to gain their perspective. Such an addition would give further depth to the statistics, and would allow a reader to relate more to the subject matter.
I also found the presentation of the statistics order to be interesting, and it may be perceived that a slight bias was included. Near the middle of the article, Richards presented four statistics in regards to the public perception of safety and officer totals. The last statistic she presented was in response to the question of whether they would like the Calgary Police Service to recruit more officers, which one-third of the interviewed responded to affirmatively.
Out of the four previously mentioned statistics, the latter-stated was the highest in percentile but for some reason was cited at the end of the paragraph. Also, it was the only statistic in the article to be presented as a fraction (one-third) rather than a percentile, which I found to be peculiar. I cannot explicitly suggest that Richards is biased towards the police service (which many reporters are), but there is a slightly subjective stance taken.
Ultimately, Richards presented the credible statistics from the CPC in a compelling manner. Asides from the two mentioned potential improvements, the article summated the report well, and concluded that although the Calgary Police Service is lacking in officer totals and that gang violence is worrisome, it is doing its job well.
References
Richards, G. (2009, October 15). Calgarians pleased with police service. Calgary Herald, p. B3.
Calgary Manhunt for Jewel Thief
By Nicolle Amyotte
I had a very difficult time with finding news this week, and failed to find an opinion article involving Calgary gangs and police instigation and treatment. I did however find an article involving news from October 20th that really interested me, as it walked through an investigation into a case of a very strategic diamond heist by gangs.
In the Calgary Herald on October 21, 2009, Jason Van Rassel wrote about the involved gangs and their tendency to stalk victims, cause eventual car breakdown, and then rob them of the diamonds or jewels that gang members realistically know the victims are in possession of. According to Van Rassel, this is an event that has been witnessed before, specifically in Red Deer.
The article goes on to explain police efforts into an investigation, particularly the methods that the police had employed, of a “manhunt” for these individuals. The police are portrayed as somewhat heroic in the article, as it was mentioned that they used a HAWC helicopter, the tactical unit, and had even interrupted the Calgary transit to seek the perpetrators out.
What I noticed about the article is that it makes no reference to the investigation surrounding the first act by these individuals which were the events that took place in Red Deer. I had no luck in locating a story about these events. Perhaps in December 2008 when the Red Deer heist occurred, the issue seemed less of an issue than a repeat offence?
Reference:
Van Rassel, J. (2009, October 21). Manhunt in Calgary after diamond heist; Red Deer robbery probed. Calgary Herald. Retreived October 21, 2009, from http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Jewel+heist+links+Deer+robbery+probed/2127344/story.html
Friday, October 2, 2009
Cuts in Funds that Hire the Heat
News by Megan Eichhorn
The Calgary Sun’s, Dave Dormer and Richard Liebrecht, reported on September 28, 2009 that the provincial government may be making budget-cuts that affect the funds used to hire cops in Alberta. Initially, one hundred new cops were to be hired in Alberta, about 30% of which would be in Calgary. Past increases in the police force have lead to a decrease in gang and drug activity in Alberta. Calgary mayor, Dave Bronconnier, feels that public safety is a spending priority and the city will hire new cops with or without provincial government funds.
Dormer and Liebrecht used quotes from government officials to establish facts in the article, as well as a statistic for the decrease in crime. The article emphasized the contradiction between Ed Stelmach’s support for crime-fighting funds and solicitor general, Fred Lindsay’s budget cuts. The issue of provincial funds to hire more cops municipally is the primary aspect of this piece.
The writers have a fairly obvious opinion on the issue, which is that Stelmach should not allow funds for policing to be cut. There is not much evidence for the other side of this issue, except Lindsay’s reasoning that, “these are tough economic times.”
Following this article, as well as Nadia Moharib’s piece from September 17, 2009, more stories that promote crime-fighting funds will probably be written, challenging the provincial government’s budget cuts by advocating statistics that crime has paused but not stopped.
Dormer, D., & Liebrecht, R. (2009, September 28). Cuts eyed for cop hiring plan. Calgary Sun. Retrieved September 29, 2009, from http://www.calgarysun.com/
Gang Migration?
Analysis by Kelsey Andersen
Following the fatal shooting that occured September 6th, 2009, The Calgary Sun's, Bill Kaufmann, began to investigate the two rival gangs that were involved. Both gangs involved reside in Alberta and neighbouring province, British Columbia. The news of the national rivals spread quickly tot he public, and many concerns, questions and debate were brought up about the migration of gangs, especially in Calgary, Alberta.
Calgary police chief, Rick Hanson, stated, "Would it be a surprise to us? Not at all, but until we can ascertain a motive, we can't say if it's something that's migrated,"
With evidence pointing in both directions, it is hard to tell if there is an actual migration going on between the B.C. and Alberta gangs. The September 6th shooting could have also arisen from a Calgary-based dispute. Hanson proceeds to promise that "It's never left our radar screen," but he also goes on to claim that police are looking out for retaliation amongst the gangs. Police forces in both provinces have been working symbiotically for quite some time, and will continue to do so.
The flow of this article was satisfactory, which gave it a more 'news-based' feeling to it, rather than more opinionated. The article seemed to be an unbiased opinion, and necessary facts were used. The author of the article, Bill Kauffmann, did a great job of getting the information out quickly without, “excess”. Kauffmann also did extremely well with communication to readers what the police were experiencing and planning to do with the issue at hand. All in all this article was very vactual, and displays a deep understanding from the Kauffmann.
B.Kauffmann. (September 8, 2009) Calgary Sun. In B.C gangs moving into Calgary? Retrieved September 29, 2009.
http://www.edmontonsun.com/news/alberta/2009/09/08/10784721-sun.html
Ban Tran!
Opinion by Nicolle Amyotte
Upon reading and being drawn in by an editorial written by an anonymous source titled, “Send Tran back” the previous day, Calgarian Masroor Ahmed penned the response Jackie Tran has worn out his welcome for the Calgary Herald on September 2, 2009. Because it is an editorial, the author is of course expressing his own opinion, which is that Jackie Tran should have been deported years ago. The writer is explicit with his viewpoint, going so far as comparing Jackie Tran to an unwelcome house guest in the manor that is Canada.
In Ahmed’s opinion, Canada should be strictly enforcing more laws to properly punish criminals, particularly gang members, for their violent activity. He states that he immigrated to
Ahmed also addresses the human rights issues that were brought up surrounding Jackie Tran’s case, and states that he has “no sympathy” for Tran’s treatment. The article he is responding to speaks of Tran’s family, also living in
Masroor, Ahmed, (2009, September 2). Jackie Tran has worn out his welcome.
Gang Violence Paused... For Now.
Analysis by James Wilt
Following the Calgary Police Service’s release of gang violence statistics on September 16th, 2009, reporter Nadia Moharib summarized the report in a concise article which was published the next day in the Calgary Sun. Within it, she utilized 4 disturbing statistics as well as accompanying quotes contributed by Chief Rick Hanson and Deputy Chief Murray Stooke.
One of the major conclusions drawn from reading Moharib’s piece is that although gang violence over the past years has become notably high, increased police presence as well as the recent arrests of ‘key players’ have contributed to a current hiatus in organized crime. However, both the statistics and the quotes directly imply that despite the fact that gang violence is paused for now, the issue is not completely solved.
From an objective perspective the article was well constructed with a non-biased, fact-based approach which was employed very effectively. Although the flow of the article wasn’t excellent, Moharib managed to sustain a neutral perspective which gave the article much more the feeling of an accurate news story than an opinion piece.
Following the conclusion of the writing, a graph of the Calgary Police Service’s statistics was presented which allowed the reader to cross-reference the writer’s commentary with fact. In conclusion, Moharib’s article analysing gang violence in Calgary was fact-based and neutral, which allowed the communication of the statistics and quotes to occur honestly and effectively.
Moharib, N. (September 17th, 2009). Calgary Sun. In Gang warfare claims 50 lives. Retrieved September 28, 2009, from http://www.calgarysun.com/news/alberta/2009/09/17/10951246-sun.html#/news/alberta/2009/09/17/pf-10951246.html .
Following the Calgary Police Service’s release of gang violence statistics on September 16th, 2009, reporter Nadia Moharib summarized the report in a concise article which was published the next day in the Calgary Sun. Within it, she utilized 4 disturbing statistics as well as accompanying quotes contributed by Chief Rick Hanson and Deputy Chief Murray Stooke.
One of the major conclusions drawn from reading Moharib’s piece is that although gang violence over the past years has become notably high, increased police presence as well as the recent arrests of ‘key players’ have contributed to a current hiatus in organized crime. However, both the statistics and the quotes directly imply that despite the fact that gang violence is paused for now, the issue is not completely solved.
From an objective perspective the article was well constructed with a non-biased, fact-based approach which was employed very effectively. Although the flow of the article wasn’t excellent, Moharib managed to sustain a neutral perspective which gave the article much more the feeling of an accurate news story than an opinion piece.
Following the conclusion of the writing, a graph of the Calgary Police Service’s statistics was presented which allowed the reader to cross-reference the writer’s commentary with fact. In conclusion, Moharib’s article analysing gang violence in Calgary was fact-based and neutral, which allowed the communication of the statistics and quotes to occur honestly and effectively.
Moharib, N. (September 17th, 2009). Calgary Sun. In Gang warfare claims 50 lives. Retrieved September 28, 2009, from http://www.calgarysun.com/